Last Thursday I attended a hustings for the UK parliamentary constituency of Edinburgh North and Leith, which was fortunate as that is where I happen to live. With exactly three weeks to go before the UK General Election I was quite excited to attend my first ever hustings, and to re-engage in politics after my self-imposed hiatus following the Scottish independence referendum.
I arrived at Broughton St Mary’s Parish Church on Bellevue Crescent and took my place amongst a hearteningly sizeable crowd of about 100 interested constituents. Looking around I observed the expected grey-haired tweed-clad gentility of the surrounding well-to-do New Town streets but also an encouraging amount of young people in normal clothes (and by that I mean under 45 and wearing jeans… I still view myself as young, no matter how deluded that sounds).
On the stage in front of the pulpit were seven austere Presbyterian wooden chairs awaiting those presumptuous enough to think they could represent us in parliament. As the clock ticked round to 7:30 the final candidate, the incumbent MP, sauntered over from the back of the hall to take up the remaining empty post. An “esteemed” local, the Financial Times Scotland Correspondent, was introduced as moderator, hushing the expectant crowd.
Each candidate, arranged in alphabetical order, was allowed two minutes to introduce themselves and say something about why they should have the dubious pleasure of attending the House of Commons on our behalf. So far, so straightforwardly pedestrian.
Unfortunately, that proved to be the high point. The first inquisitor seemed to have little grasp of the concept of the question and rambled on about herself and her feminist manifesto before being interrupted and the panel asked about their views on why it has taken so long for an Equal Pay Act, passed decades ago, to have any discernible impact on pay levels for women. Each candidate spouted platitudes for 90 seconds, a hotel receptionist’s bell having been acquired to cut short the verbose, before, bizarrely, a new question was taken without further ado.
It became clear that our esteemed moderator could have been a six-year-old child, such was the requirement for him to merely point at people with their hands up to ask a question. Candidates could spout any old unsubstantiated nonsense, and they did, with no proper challenge (apart from candidates who were speaking after them, in strict alphabetical order of course). The questioner was not allowed to put their view or say whether the candidates had suitably answered their question.
During a question surrounding the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) my heart soared as an eccentrically dressed gentleman with quite magnificent facial hair started heckling… politics had broken out at last! Unfortunately a wave of tweed-clad tutting washed across the hall, throwing the starched disapproval of Edinburgh’s self-important tweederati upon our free-spirited pebble as it broke over his individuality.
I found myself thrown back to my childhood Sunday mornings, press-ganged as I had been to attend similar gatherings of outwardly pious neighbours dressed to show their status in the community. The ostensible reason for communing with god in reality only an opportunity to confirm their superiority in society through mutual disapproval of outsiders. Here again I found myself repelled by my cosy, smug “betters” showering disdain on anyone who dared to think differently, as clearly society was working just fine for them so why change it.
The admirable attempt by some to challenge this comfortable orthodoxy by asking pertinent questions were dulled by the stultifying format to such an extent that the boredom you are probably feeling right now propelled me from my seat and out into the crisp spring evening. On completing the short walk home I tweeted my exasperation at the crushingly dull nature of the event to the organisers and was invited to share my thoughts on how to improve future meetings; an invitation I have taken up although I’m not sure I can bring myself to find out if they ever take my advice.
One lost evening is probably enough.
*For a report of the event from the organisers, the local paper The Broughton Spurtle, click here.